Digital platforms have hollowed out local journalism. Here are some ideas on how to make them pay.

By Daniela Rynott

Bolstering independent local news organizations would counter the corporate monopolization of media and strengthen democratic participation. But how should that be done? Major philanthropic initiatives such as Press Forward, which has invested more than $600 million in community journalism, are helping to expand coverage. State assistance in the form of tax credits and grant programs have been approved in California, Illinois, New Jersey and elsewhere.

Here’s another idea: The federal government could impose a tax on targeted digital advertising revenue and direct the proceeds to a public fund dedicated exclusively to local and regional journalism.

Online tech platforms such as Google, Facebook and TikTok have come to dominate the media industry. Local journalism has been left behind, resulting in the closure of thousands of newspapers across the country. According to Northwestern University’s Medill Local News Initiative, the number of nondaily local newspapers declined from 7,345 in 2005 to 4,482 in 2025, while daily newspapers fell from 1,566 to just 937.

Where local news wanes, civic engagement suffers. In a 2021 study published in The Journal of Politics, political scientist Daniel Moskowitz found that voters with greater exposure to local news coverage were more likely to split their tickets between presidential and statewide candidates, suggesting that quality news and information helps people to make independent judgments rather than voting strictly along party lines. Other studies have found that a lack of local news leads to lower voter turnout and a decrease in the number of candidates running for political office as well as an increase in corruption.

The decline of local journalism has provided room for digital platforms to rise, leading to a complete reshaping the media economy. Much of the advertising revenue that once sustained newsrooms has been redirected to social media, which relies on targeted advertising. The economic displacement caused by the rise of digital has left local outlets unable to compete.

A federal digital advertising tax would redirect a portion of this revenue toward rebuilding the civic infrastructure these platforms have displaced. The Media Power Collaborative, a coalition led by the media-reform organization Free Press Action, has proposed a 1% tax on advertising revenue from major technology and corporate platforms. According to Free Press, the tax could generate billions of dollars nationally to support local journalism.

There is already precedent for this approach. Maryland implemented a digital advertising tax in 2021, with rates ranging from 2.5% to 10% depending on a company’s global annual revenue. According to researchers Chi Nguyen and Robert Seamans of the Brookings Institution, the tax has generated revenue for public education — a tangible example of how digital advertising can fund public services. Technology policy researchers Alessia Zornetta and Thomas Ash have also estimated that a 1% advertising tax on major platforms could generate approximately $135 million annually in California alone.

Because digital advertising operates on a national scale, federal implementation would best ensure effective regulation, but if this were to happen, funds should be distributed to state and local journalism initiatives to preserve community accountability. Although federal efforts to provide funding to local news fell short even before Donald Trump was elected to a second term as president, the possibility of a Democratic president and Congress starting in 2029 could present a new opportunity.

A five-year rollout

 A framework for how such a plan might pan out entails a gradual, five-year rollout, with an initial focus on communities struggling the most with newsroom closures. During the first two years, Congress might establish a tax framework, with the Internal Revenue Service developing criteria to determine which platforms would be subject to taxation.

The second phase, spanning the third and fourth years, would prioritize communities most affected by the collapse of local journalism. These areas, known as “news deserts,” are concentrated in rural regions and low-income communities where traditional subscription-based models struggle to sustain reporting. States with particularly low numbers of journalists per capita would receive priority grant allocations.

Beginning in the fifth year, the program would expand nationally, making grants available to qualifying news organizations across all 50 states. Congress would review the program’s performance every five years, adjusting the tax rate and funding criteria as necessary.

The distribution of these funds must remain independent of elected officials. A major concern surrounding public funding for journalism is the possibility that government might exert pressure on news organizations, threatening to withhold funding from outlets that publish unfavorable coverage.

To prevent this, funds must be distributed through a nonpartisan public media trust insulated from both the executive branch and Congress. This trust would be run by journalists, academic experts and community representatives rather than political appointees.

One existing model is the New Jersey Civic Information Consortium, which provides grants of up to $100,000 for projects serving underserved communities and has disbursed some $12.9 million for local news and information since it was established in 2021. The consortium is governed by a nonpartisan board, and state law prohibits government officials from exercising editorial control over grant recipients. Its structure demonstrates that public money can support journalism without compromising editorial independence.

Under the proposed federal model, the trust would distribute funding to state-level journalism funds, which would administer grants to newsrooms within their jurisdictions. States would be required to publish transparent allocation criteria, including community population size, newsroom employment and the availability of existing local coverage.

Eligibility requirements would also be essential. Without proper oversight, chain-owned corporate newspaper owners such as USA Today Co. (formerly Gannett) and Alden Global Capital could be eligible for grant funding even though they have drastically cut the amount of local news they cover. Similarly, without safeguards, newsrooms could use public money to subsidize AI-generated content rather than employing human reporters.

To prevent this, qualifying newsrooms would need to demonstrate a commitment to original local reporting and maintain a human journalism staff. Smaller outlets unable to meet staffing requirements because of financial constraints could apply for exceptions, ensuring the program does not exclude the very newsrooms it intends to support.

Of course, the proposal would face significant opposition. Major technology companies would likely argue that the tax stifles innovation and economic growth. Digital advertising taxes could also lead platforms to increase advertising prices, passing costs onto small businesses. Policymakers should therefore establish high revenue thresholds so that only the largest platforms are taxed, leaving smaller digital publishers unaffected.

Ensuring independence

Critics may also argue that government funding threatens press freedom. The current system, though, already exposes journalism to coercion, with for-profit news organizations facing pressure from advertisers and nonprofits from philanthropic donors. Public funding with strong structural protections can therefore increase, rather than diminish, journalistic independence.

While other approaches, including foundation grants and digital subscriptions, have produced some success, they cannot reliably sustain journalism in every community. Public investment would provide a more stable funding source without depending on individual consumers’ ability to pay, especially in underserved rural areas that foundations tend to ignore.

Ultimately, this policy is not so much a reinvention of journalism as a redirection of resources. It would return a fraction of the wealth generated by digital platforms to the local newsrooms that have lost their primary revenue stream. Increased funding would create journalism jobs, restore local political coverage and help reverse the civic disengagement accompanying the disappearance of community newspapers.

Protecting democracy requires proactive investment, even in the face of political resistance. Reviving local journalism is not simply about saving newspapers. It is about restoring citizens’ connections to the political institutions and decisions that most directly affect their lives.

Daniela Rynott is a second-year undergraduate student at Northeastern University majoring in journalism and political science.

Rob Curley is out at The Spokesman-Review, though the fate of his nonprofit remains uncertain

Rob Curley earlier this year via CreativeMorning Spokane’s YouTube channel.

By Dan Kennedy

When last we left Rob Curley, his hopes of transferring ownership of The Spokesman-Review to a nonprofit he’d founded were hanging in the balance. Curley had been suspended as executive editor of the Spokane, Washington-based daily amid allegations of serious workplace misconduct — yet the paper’s owners had agreed several years ago to donate it to Curley’s nonprofit venture, the Comma Community Journalism Lab.

Now it looks like this saga is coming to a close, although — as has been the case since August, when Curley was suspended — the situation remains incredibly messy. Spokesman-Review publisher William Stacey Cowles announced Tuesday that Curley is officially out as executive editor and that the donation of the paper to Comma is off. Cowles told Spokesman-Review reporter Nina Culver that the for-profit paper would continue under family ownership, saying, “We are committed to having the newspaper remain a pillar of local journalism.”

Read the rest at Media Nation.

How to fight back against AI-generated local news and pink slime: double down on civic engagement

The Adams Building in Lexington Center, the former home of the now-defunct Lexington Minuteman. Photo (cc) 2022 by Dan Kennedy.

By Dan Kennedy

AI-generated local news has been part of the Greater Boston scene for a while. Among the more prominent examples is South Shore News, which actually charges a subscription fee for readers who want to keep up with municipal government meetings in the 19 communities that it reaches.

In just the past month or two, though, I’ve noticed a sudden uptick. We’ve gone from a few AI outlets here and there to a plethora, often competing with organic startup projects. Now Maggie Scales, a reporter for The Lexington Observer, has taken their measure, noting that there are four AI networks in Lexington alone — the Lexington-Concord Courier, Nanopress, Townbrief and GatherGov.

“To put it bluntly, I think it’s garbage,” Jesse Floyd, editor-in-chief of The Belmont Voice, told Scales.

Read the rest at Media Nation.

How Mike Shapiro expanded his TAPinto network into a more flexible suite of publishing services

On the latest “What Works” podcast, Dan and Ellen talk with Mike Shapiro, a friend of the pod. He came on in 2022 to talk about his role as founder and CEO of TAPinto, a network of nearly 100 franchised local news and digital marketing sites serving more than 150 communities in New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania and Florida.

Shapiro is a graduate of Rutgers and Stanford Law School, but he’s got the journalism bug as well. He was working as an attorney in New York when his young son underwent open-heart surgery. Because he wanted to spend more time at home, he and his wife, Lauryn, launched The Alternative Press in 2008 to give their hometown of New Providence, New Jersey, an independent, all-digital daily news source.

Pretty soon, neighboring towns asked for their own sites, and a network was born. In 2013 Shapiro repositioned TAPinto as a franchise model: local owners run their own sites, while the company supplies the technology, training and back-office support. Franchisees share content and sell advertising across the network.

But now, he’s expanded the business model again. In 2024 he launched the Hyperlocal News Network, a licensing option that gives publishers more freedom to control their own branding but helps with those vexing back-office needs.

Ellen has a Quick Take on The Minnesota Star Tribune‘s lack of endorsements in some very consequential state races. The Strib’s editorial board didn’t interrogate candidates, do its own reporting and weigh in on who would make the best governor or senator. Instead, op-ed columnists wrote in support of each candidate. The Strib called these columns “closing arguments.”

Dan has a Quick Take about OpenAI’s support for local journalism. On the one hand, it’s a welcome development. On the other hand, he’s worried that news organizations may be getting co-opted by a technology they should remain deeply skeptical of. Will newsrooms shy away from critical coverage of AI lest they offend the golden goose?

You can listen here, or you can subscribe through your favorite podcast app.

Six reporting lessons from the Cornell University sexual assault investigation

Photo (cc) 2024 via Wikimedia Commons.

By Namira Haris

This article was first published in Storybench, a publication about data and digital storytelling based at Northeastern University’s School of Journalism.

From student journalists who stayed with the story for nearly two years to national newsrooms parsing police interviews, Title IX records and court documents, coverage of the Cornell case offers lessons for reporters tackling sensitive, document-heavy investigations.

When a former Cornell University student filed a civil lawsuit in September alleging that she had been drugged and sexually assaulted by several fraternity members in 2024, the case quickly drew national attention.

But for reporters at student-run Cornell Daily Sun, the story wasn’t new.

Continue reading “Six reporting lessons from the Cornell University sexual assault investigation”

Longtime Boston political analyst Jon Keller tells us about the art of moderating debates

Jon Keller analyzes the recent gubernatorial debate that he moderated. Photo via YouTube.

On the brand-new “What Works” podcast, Dan talks with Jon Keller, who has been explaining Massachusetts politics to Boston broadcast audiences for nearly half a century. Ellen couldn’t make it on air for this episode, but she handled the editing and will be back soon.

Jon returned to WBZ-TV just in time to cover a contentious governor’s election. He brought his trademark quick thinking and level-headed approach to the recent debate between Democratic incumbent Maura Healey and her Republican challenger, Mike Minogue. Jon was a colleague of Dan’s at The Boston Phoenix, where he wrote a political column. His “Keller @ Large” show remains one of the longest-running political franchises in local television.

Boston magazine twice named him “Best TV Political Analyst,” and he’s won a boatload of New England Emmys. In the Jurassic era, Jon wrote an opinion column for Ellen at The Boston Globe, and today he writes a column for the MASSterlist political newsletter.

Jon has also been caught in the Paramount media swirl as well. WBZ-TV laid him off in October 2025 as part of Paramount’s cuts, but WBZ brought him back as a special contributor in March of this year.

Dan’s got a Quick Take about turmoil at The Spokesman-Review in Spokane, Washington. Executive editor Rob Curley, who’s leading an effort to take the paper nonprofit, was placed on administrative leave recently for unspecified inappropriate behavior. Now a deeply reported article by two nonprofit news outlets tells devastating story about what went wrong.

You can listen here, or you can subscribe through your favorite podcast app.

How Rob Curley’s plan to take The Spokesman-Review nonprofit ended in a newsroom revolt

Rob Curley, Michael McCarter and David Dunn-Rankin discuss the future of newspaper opinion content at the 2025 America’s Newspapers Mega-Conference in Orlando. Moderated by Editor & Publisher’s Mike Blinder, the panel is featured in Episode 281 of “E&P Reports.”

By Wilson Criscione and Daisy Zavala Magaña

This report was produced in a collaboration between InvestigateWest and RANGE and republished by permission.

When The Spokesman-Review announced plans to transfer Spokane’s 143-year-old, family-owned newspaper to a nonprofit founded by Executive Editor Rob Curley, it took over the front page.

“The People’s Paper,” read the April 16, 2025, headline, saying ownership would transfer “to you, the community.”

Key to the plan was Curley, the folksy self-proclaimed “journalism nerd” who burst into Spokane a decade ago, declaring a love for Gonzaga University basketball rivaled only by his love for Disney. The transition to Comma Community Journalism Lab was cast in media industry publications not only as a way to save Spokane’s daily newspaper, but as part of a growing movement to resurrect dying papers by making them less dependent on ads and corporate ownership and more on philanthropy and community partnerships. As proof of concept, the paper had already added several so-called “community-funded” journalists to its staff.

But in The Spokesman-Review newsroom this summer, that hopeful vision ran into persistent concerns about Curley’s leadership. More than a dozen current and former employees, along with contemporaneous records reviewed by InvestigateWest and RANGE, reveal how the newsroom had raised concerns about Curley’s management for years, culminating in his suspension from the paper on Aug. 7 and a vote of no confidence from the union, the Spokane Editorial Society. He is currently on leave as the paper conducts an internal investigation.

Continue reading “How Rob Curley’s plan to take The Spokesman-Review nonprofit ended in a newsroom revolt”

Clay Wirestone tells us how opinion journalists brought voice and authority to local news in Kansas

Clay Wirestone ignores the cookies. Photo by Sherman Smith.

On the latest “What Works” podcast, Dan and Ellen talk with Clay Wirestone, the opinion editor of the Kansas Reflector, a digital nonprofit that’s part of the States Newsroom network. His first book was published Sept. 29. It’s called, aptly enough, “Opinionated: Kansas Journalists Who Proved Why Commentary Matters — Then and Now.” His second is scheduled for 2028.

Wirestone seems to be on a first-name basis with Kansas opinion journalists past and present, and he profiles a number of them. He knows the state well: he graduated from the University of Kansas and lives in Lawrence with his husband. He also edited news at The Topeka Capital-Journal and spent more than a decade at New Hampshire’s Concord Monitor,  where he worked with Dan’s Northeastern colleague Meg Heckman, a past guest on this podcast.

Dan has a Quick Take about yet another new book — “Deserted: Life Without Local News in Rural America,” by Nick Mathews. Dan reviewed it recently for The Arts Fuse. Mathews offers some interesting insights into what happens to community life when there’s a shortage of reliable news and information.

Ellen’s Quick Take is on an excellent Substack post by media observer Richard J. Tofel on the recent massacre at the McClatchy newspaper chain, which is being gutted by its private-equity owner. It’s like a slasher movie, and the slasher has come for newspapers that were great in their heyday.

You can listen here, or you can subscribe through your favorite podcast app.

INN’s NewsMatch program switches from an annual fundraising drive to a year-round effort

From “NewsMatch at 10: A Decade of Impact.”

For nonprofit news organizations, the most important time of the year is November and December, when the NewsMatch program goes live. An initiative of the Institute for Nonprofit News, the program provides national funding as a percentage of money raised locally. It’s not a one-to-one match, but it provides crucial revenues to small (and large) projects as well as an incentive they can use in attracting donors.

Now INN is making a change. According to a new impact report, marking the 10th anniversary of the program, NewsMatch is moving to a year-round model. According to the report:

The next phase will focus on helping newsrooms build on that foundation with more advanced, flexible campaigns tailored to their goals and stage of growth. To support this evolution, NewsMatch is shifting from a single year-end campaign to a year-round model.

We talked to newsrooms about what they were looking for from this opportunity, and they emphasized the value of flexibility, experimentation, and shared learning. In 2027, we’re excited to pilot NewsMatch Catalyst Campaigns, supporting a select group of INN members as they test new fundraising strategies, deepen donor engagement, and build toward long-term sustainability.

According to the report, NewsMatch has raised more than $477 million for local news over the past 10 years, with INN itself growing from 27 investigative news organizations in 2009 to some 500 member outlets today. (INN was originally known as the Investigative News Network.)

Karen Rundlet, INN’s CEO and executive director, calls NewsMatch “the people-powered engine of the nonprofit news field, democratizing donations from a public that wants good, accurate information that helps them with daily decision making. People from all corners of the country donate to newsrooms via NewsMatch.”

Sophie Culpepper of Nieman Lab has a good overview of the impact report.

Margaret Sullivan tells us how national media failures connect with the local news crisis

Margaret Sullivan. Photo (cc) 2016 by Michaelbenabib.

The “What Works” podcast is back after our summer hiatus. Ellen was feeling under the weather, so Dan is flying solo. But no worries — Ellen still handled editing and production, and she should be back for our next episode.

We’re pleased to have Margaret Sullivan as our guest. Sullivan has spent the last decade or so doing the toughest of jobs: telling the country’s most powerful newsrooms what they’re getting wrong. She was the fifth public editor at The New York Times, from 2012 to 2016. Somebody once called it the worst job in journalism, but she took it anyway. Then she went to The Washington Post as its media columnist, where she covered the 2016 and 2020 elections, the Trump years, and the insurrection of Jan. 6, 2021. She left the Post in 2022, which, in hindsight, looks like excellent timing.

Sullivan writes a weekly column on media, politics and culture for The Guardian US, and she publishes a fearless newsletter on Substack called American Crisis, where she calls out lapses in how the media are covering Donald Trump’s authoritarianism.

But she also has deep roots in local journalism. She was a summer intern at her hometown paper, The Buffalo News, and worked her way up to become its first woman editor-in-chief. So she knows firsthand what happens to a community when its newspaper is gutted. In 2020, she published a book about the local news crisis called “Ghosting the News: Local Journalism and the Crisis of American Democracy” and, we’re pleased to say, she blurbed our book, “What Works in Community News.”

Dan has a Quick Take that Yogi Berra would have called déjà vu all over again. The Block family, which owns The Blade newspaper in Toledo, Ohio, says it will shut down the paper if they can’t find a buyer by the end of 2026. Now where have we heard that before? He also dives into the new impact report from the American Journalism Project, a philanthropic organization that turns out to be one of the biggest funders of nonprofit news in the country. AJP makes the case that nonprofit news as a business model has moved past the experimental stage.

You can listen here, or you can subscribe through your favorite podcast app.